Difference between revisions of "Gap feedbacks"

From GapWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
((2) Nice to have)
(Blanked the wikidb.page)
 
Line 1: Line 1:
== (1) Bugs/Features that need to be checked==
 
  
+ Sometimes the URL is http://www.gapmaps.org/GAP.Protected/, sometimes http://www.gapmaps.org/gap.protected/ and it is not clear why. Also the GEOPEDIA in the Wiki URL should not be there anymore (JOEL, JAKOB)
 
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed (production environment) </span>''
 
 
+ Editing point symbology based on filters does not work if 'Apply' is clicked straight away. They do not change after closing the symbology tab, the lines with edited symbology disappear. (JAKOB)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> We have to look at this together, i cant reproduce it. I tried FF and Chrome. </span>''
 
 
+ In the documentation / GAP Help, please add the functionality to allow <math>-tags to be interpreted (for use in writing mathematical formulas). (JOEL)
 
 
 
+ All Links on the main page need to be redirected to the main Help page (JAKOB).
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. (Check if all links are correct) </span>''
 
 
+ In the printed Map, there is now the 'Map Data(c)2015 Google' printed all over the place (see here for example: [[http://test-gap.eawag.ch/GAP.Geopedia/index.php?title=File%3AScreen_Shot_2015-09-17_at_17.42.15.png#file]]. This makes the maps rather unusable for a nice report. (JAKOB)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> I am aware of this problem and searching for a fix.  </span>''
 
 
 
+ The order of layers is generally (like in ArcGis) that the top one in the list is the visible one and overlays all others below. On GAP it is the other way round, I find that counterintuitive (see in screenshot here, where 'final' is the model result and 'mekonggis' are the points: [http://test-gap.eawag.ch/GAP.Geopedia/index.php?title=File%3ALayerOrder.png]). This should be changed. (JAKOB)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#FF0000"> Generally works, but sometimes not. For example, the 'Up' and 'Down' buttons sometimes do not respond and the top layer in the list is sometimes not displayed on the surface of the map. I cannot reliably reproduce this, but I used three layers, and the problems seemed to appear after much repositioning of layers. (JOEL) </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> I tried it with Chrome, FF, IE and Safari. It works as expected. If you can reproduce it please send me screen shots + detail description. </span>''
 
 
 
+ My Layers > Symbology: add (or rename 'Apply' to) a 'DONE' button to the center bottom of the windows 'Upload', 'Share', 'Symbology', 'Point Symbology', 'Point Symbology' > 'Graphic' & 'Filter', 'Raster Symbology', 'Raster Symbology' > 'Statistics', 'Polygon Symbology' and 'Polygon Symbology' > 'Fill', 'Line' & 'Filter' to accept changes and close window (nicer to not HAVE to click the x in the upper right). (JOEL)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed for most of them. I think it doesn't look nice.Instead of that we could have changed the "close" icon.  </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#FF0000"> I agree that 'Close' would be better than 'Done', and this should be applied consistently. Perhaps 'Close' should be used for windows in which no further user input needs to be registered and 'OK' used in other windows to implement user changes and close a window. What do you think? (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. See feedback on buttons. </span>''
 
 
 
+ Statistical Analysis: Please add headings to the top of the following screens in order for users to better know where they are: "Data tables" for the main Data screen; "Edit data table" for Data > Edit; "Create data table" for Data > Edit; "Models" for the main Models screen; "Create model" for Models > Create; "Model statistics" for Models > View Stats. The text at the top, "This step prepares a data table..." can be moved to the bottom of the screen. (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. I think they should be called "Modelling tables", "Edit modelling table" and "Create modelling table". It should be clear for users that this tables are only used for modelling. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#FF0000"> I agree that "model" should be in every heading, though isn't "table" a little confusing, especially since "table" is used throughout the data tables? I understand the use of "table" is this context to mean </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#FF0000"> data organized in something like a spreadsheet and not the tables with a row for each dataset or model as displayed on these screens. Is this correct? If so, "tables" should be used only with the data,  </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#FF0000"> and only the term "model" is sufficient to describe the modelling windows.  (JOEL) </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> I modified titles, check them again.  </span>''
 
 
 
+ About: Please add the correct URLs to the various links or remove them. (JOEL)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#FF0000"> A couple of things still need updating. GAP Maps: "register" should probably be made into a link; Change last two sentences to, "For how-to instructions and to discover </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#FF0000"> the full potential of GAP Maps, please see GAP Help." GAP Help should then link to the Help page (currently to GAP Wiki). GAP Wiki -> 1st sentence: Link "GAP Wiki" at the </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#FF0000"> beginning of sentence to GAP Wiki. Remove last 4 words such that sentence ends with "...your own article."; Change the two occurrences of "the GAP Wiki" to "GAP Wiki". </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#FF0000"> Remove the last two sentences (obviously one will go to GAP Wiki to learn more about it, and GAP Help otherwise does not describe GAP Wiki). (JOEL) [[Media:JP_bug_012.png]] </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed.  </span>''
 
 
+ Main page: Please move the 'About' link to the bottom, remove the 'Contact' link' (info already in About) and otherwise arrange the links as follows.
 
TOP BAR: 'GAP Maps' ¦ 'GAP Help' ¦ 'GAP Wiki'
 
BOTTOM BAR: 'About' ¦ 'Terms of Use' ¦ '© Eawag, 2015'(JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Isn't this exactly what i initially developed? You guys asked me to change it and now you want all the changes to be reverted. Please make sure this is the last decision.
 
It is just a waste of time and money.  </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#FF0000"> Yes, final decision. Promise. :) (JOEL) </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed.  </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ Buttons should remain as consistent as possible throughout the application.
 
 
'OK' & 'Cancel' at the middle-bottom of the follow windows: My Layers > Share Layer; My Layers > Symbology; My Layers > Symbology > Symbol; My Layers > Symbology > Filter; Statistical Analysis > Data > Create data table; Statistical Analysis > Models > Add.
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed.  </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#FF0000"> Please change 'Ok' to 'OK' everywhere. On 'My Layers > Symbology > Symbol', is it not possible to add the Cancel functionality and button? (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
'Add' & 'Remove' in the following windows: My Layers; Statistical Analysis > Data; Statistical Analysis > Data > Edit data table (buttons next to each other); Statistical Analysis > Models
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed.  </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ My Layers > Add: Change button from "Done" to "Close". (JOEL)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed.  </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ My Layers > Symbology (raster) > Statistics: It would be nice to have the 'Calculating raster statistics' message displayed in the middle of the window (currently upper-left). (JOEL)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed.  </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#FF0000"> It still appears up and to the left of center. My sense is that this is an improvement, though I don't recall how it appeared before (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ About > Contact: Please add roles to the two contact names: "Annette Johnson, Project Manager, johnson@eawag.ch"; "Joel Podgorski, Technical Support, joel.podgorski@eawag.ch" (JOEL)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed.  </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ Front page: Please have the cursor change to a hand (as with the other links) when mousing over the 'GAP Maps' and 'GAP Wiki' tiles/links. (JOEL)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed.  </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ Team Page - it should be on the site, not an iFrame of a PDF as this is very difficult to scroll through and in my resolution does not look professional. I had to make the PDF much smaller to see it fully and identify team members. [http://test-gap.eawag.ch/GAP.Geopedia/index.php?title=File%3ATeamPage.png] (JAKOB)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed.  </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
== (2) Nice to have==
 
 
+ To provide the chance to users to leave their feedback on the site we could implement a feedback button (like: usabilla.com) on the site. This would gather feedback automatically which one could implement at regular instances (discussed in meeting, JAKOB)
 
 
+ the site needs a page somewhere for frequently asked questions (FAQ, once we have enough of them from External Testing and other users). (discussed in meeting, JAKOB)
 
 
+ It would be good to have an option on GapMaps that brings you back to the initial main page with one click. (JAKOB).
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> You can click on GAP logo anywhere in the application (also in the wiki) to go to front page. </span>''
 
 
+ The site needs a proper Stats Counter (country, time on site, clicks on site, which sites accessed etc.). (JAKOB).
 
 
+ In the long run it would be idea to have a more customizable map (possibly choosing where the legend is placed, how titles are written etc.). (JAKOB).
 
 
+ In 'My Layers' it has to be possible to edit the name of a layer without having to upload it again. (JAKOB).
 
 
+ When registering it should be possible to provide one's name (JAKOB).
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Added field "Name" to the registration page. (production) </span>''
 
 
+ When applying a model there should be an option to upload your own extent for the model (as for eample a shp file) so the model output will be limited exactly to this area. (JAKOB)
 
 
+ When I click on 'Register' it takes me to the Log In Page. There should be a page that informs about the 'confirmation email' however and only after I confirm is it possible to Log In (JAKOB)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
 
+ If I want to remove multiple layers I have to remove each layer separately. This is quite tedious. It would be more convenient to be able to select multiple layers and remove them all at once. (JAKOB)
 
 
+ Statistical Analysis > Modelling > Preprocessing > Edit: ‘Select column’ dropdown should retain the last expansion state of folders used (so that you don’t have to again click through the directory tree to get where you last were). (JOEL)
 
 
+ A solution (forum type) will need to be found for users to comment on data quality directly at a dataset. (JAKOB).
 
 
+ To share with a user I always have to know the first three letters of his/her email adress to find the correct one. This should be better searchable (Name, parts of email adress, etc). When I type 'j', 'jakob steiner' should appear as well as 'joel' and 'annette johnson'.(JAKOB)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Adopted the current function to return a complete list. </span>''
 
 
+ There needs to be a rigurous check of the site on all Browsers at one point (Chrome, Firefox, IExplorer, Safari). This should also be something we should ask testers, to specify their Browser. On the long run, we should also keep in mind compatibility on Tablets, this is actually something the guy from SDC asked me last time ... (JAKOB)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Good point. I regularly check the functions in FF and Chrome. As we use html5, some of the elements might not appear as expected in IE and safari. Who is going to help testing on other browsers? </span>''
 
 
+ The Sending a message to Community does not seem to work anymore [http://test-gap.eawag.ch/GAP.Geopedia/images/d/dd/Screen_Shot_2015-08-07_at_17.21.08.png]. Also when it still worked and messages showed up, the message was not sent to the group's emails. (Jakob)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Please move this to nice to have. This function has not been implemented. We have to decide whether we should implement it or not. </span>''
 
 
+ When I delete my account there should be a window that asks 'Are you sure you want to delete your account? Yes/No' (JAKOB)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Please move this to nice to have. This function has not been implemented. We have to decide whether we should implement it or not. </span>''
 
 
== (3) Feedback on HELP Page==
 
 
+ the plots still need to be formatted properly, the way they look now they can not be used (see issues above as well) (JAKOB).
 
 
+ sample plots should have reasonable data plotted, not just some strangely named dummy data, would not look professional (JAKOB).
 
 
+ for the more complex steps how-to-videos are suggested, those will be made when the site does not change anymore, otherwise they have to be redone continuously (JAKOB)
 
 
 
+ Revise the section on Symbology as at the moment it is executed in a very basic fashion. (JAKOB)
 
 
+ Following was fixed and now needs to be explained in the HELP section: When I open the table I shared I have added arsenics there previously but it does not show. I have to retry it a couple of times and then it somehow works. This issue I don’t quite understand yet, it seems to be limited to community layers. (JAKOB)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. If a shared table is open for editing by a community member, other members can't edit it. I return a message to show the table is used by another person. To avoid this, make sure after editing a table you close it using the "close" button. </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff">If you just close the window, the state of table remains "open" and other members wont edit it. Simultaneous editing a table is not allowed.  </span>''
 
 
== (4) Fixed Bugs ==
 
 
+ Manage your account: change mouseover to "Manage Account". Change top headline of page from "Manage." to "Manage Account" (JOEL)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ Print: change title of window from "Print..." to "Print" (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ Print: change field name from "Map Title" to "Map title" (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ Maps > Toolbar: mouseovers need to be updated to match the current names of the windows/pages that they open - 'Layers', 'My Layers', 'Statistical Analysis', 'Communities', 'Manage Account', 'Print' (JOEL)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ Main page: change "Login" to "Log in". Although the former is technically correct, the latter is more clearly a verb and is consistent with the label of the opposite function, "Log off". (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ Register: I would prefer to see "Register." changed to "Register" and "Create a new account." to "Create a new account". Both of these strings should also be left-aligned. (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ My Layers: rename button from 'Add' to 'Upload'. "Add" can be interpreted to mean "add layer already in list to map", which is of course not the case. (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ My Layers > Add (Upload): rename window from "Upload your data" to "Upload Data". (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ My Layers > Add (Upload): change the names of all file types to the singular: "point", "Coverage", "raster". (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ Communities: rename button from 'Details' to 'Info', which more closely matches the name of the window that is opened. "Information" is probably still the best term to use, since this is more general than "details" and probably applies better to the user information and messages contained in this window. (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed.  </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ Communities > Details (Info): rename column from "Is admin" to "Admin". (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ When I provide symbology for different rules, I can not shoft these lines 'up' or 'down'. This then reflects in the legend as well. If I have the highest value in the first line, the lowest in the second and the one in the middle in the last, the legend will be all over the place. It should be possible to move these lines around like the layers [http://test-gap.eawag.ch/GAP.Geopedia/index.php?title=File%3ASymbologyOrder.png] (JAKOB)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ When I delete layers in 'My Layers' and then go to 'Statistical modeling', those layers are still there. However when I want to access them it throws an error message. They should not be visible anymore after I have deleted them from my layers. (JAKOB)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ My Layers > Raster Symbology: I feel like there does not need to be a confirmation dialog box when changing the color scale type. This seems easy enough to switch back and forth, and having to click 'Yes' on an additional dialog seems a little tedious. (JOEL)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ My Layers: Rename "Visualize" to "Display". "Visualize" is not entirely incorrect, but it is typically used in the context of imagining something in your head. "Display", on the other hand, is more appropriate for a computing environment. (JOEL)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ My Layers > Point Symbology: How about changing the button name from "Graphic" to "Symbol"? I realize that this is very close to "symbology", but "symbol" is the best way that I would describe what is being modified when clicking on 'Graphic'. (JOEL)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#FF0000"> Not fixed, but also not critical. Do you agree that 'Symbol' would be an improvement over 'Graphic'? (JOEL) </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed again. </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ The ‘Maps&Tools’ (to be ‘GAP Maps’) link in the top bar should be highlighted but inactive on the GAP Maps page. It is important for users to know where they are, but a link at it currently is is somewhat confusing (What other Maps&Tools could I go to?).
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. I made the link disabled. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ All instances of ‘Maps&Tools’ should be renamed to ‘GAP Maps’ (complements the name ‘GAP Wiki’ very well). (JOEL)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''GAP_Wiki
 
  ''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ The link to ‘Documentation’ should be renamed and go to ‘GAP Wiki’. (JOEL)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ My Layers > Upload Data: please add a 'DONE' box to the right of the 'Upload' button to offer another option for closing this window. (JOEL)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ Statistical Analysis > Descriptive Statistics: The label "Select Layer:" should be changed to "Select layer:" to be consistent with the other label "Select an attribute:". (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ Statistical Analysis > Descriptive Statistics: The prompt "Select layer(s) from the dropdown list" should be disappear once a layer has actually been selected. Otherwise, it seems like this step still needs to be made. Moreover, the dropdown is still labeled ("Select layer:") for someone wanting to change the displayed layer. (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ Statistical Analysis > Descriptive Statistics: Text below graph, "Cumulative distribution of..." should be justified with the left edge of the chart (similar to "Select an attribute:") and given some space between the it and the graph. (JOEL)
 
  ''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#FF0000"> This is admittedly nitpicking, but the text is not aligned perfectly at the left edge and it would look better to have more space between the graph and text. (JOEL) </span>''
 
  ''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ Statistical Analysis > Models: Change text at bottom to: "Green indicates a good AUC. Yellow indicates a poor AUC.". (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ Welcome page & GAP Maps page: Please change the 'GAP Wiki' link to point to the GAP_Wiki page. We have made the Documentation page redundant such that it need no longer be used. (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ Statistical Analysis > Data: heading changes - "Base Table" to "Base table" and "last Update" to "Last update" (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ Main page: Please change "Legal notice and disclaimer" to "Terms of Use" (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#FF0000"> Please also change window name from "Disclaimer" to "Terms of Use". (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ About:  Please change all occurrences of the following terms: "the Maps & Tools" to "GAP Maps"; "the GapPedia" to "GAP Wiki"; "Team&Partners" to "Team"; "GAP-Team" to "GAP team"; "GAP-tools" to "GAP tools"; "the Help Section on the GapPedia" to "GAP Help" (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 
 
+ About: Please remove references to "How to use GAP Maps & Tools” [pdf]" (JOEL)
 
''<span style="color:#0000ff"> Fixed. </span>''
 
''<span style="color:#00CC00"> CONFIRMED (JOEL) </span>''
 

Latest revision as of 22:23, 18 September 2019